Ohio fishing scandal: 2 men caught cheating at tournament charged, prosecutors say

FILE - A volunteer prepares to release a walleye caught at the Brainerd Jaycees Ice Fishing Extravaganza fishing tournament on Gull Lake on Jan. 26, 2008, in Brainerd, Minnesota. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

Two men accused of cheating at a fishing tournament in Ohio by stuffing walleye with lead weights and fillets in an attempt to win the cash grand prize have been charged, authorities announced on Wednesday. 

The anglers, Jacob Runyan, 42, of Broadview Heights, Ohio, and Chase Cominski, 35, of Hermitage, Pennsylvania, were indicted in Cleveland on felony charges of cheating, attempted grand theft, possessing criminal tools, and misdemeanor charges of unlawfully owning wild animals. They're due to be arraigned on Oct. 26.

"I take all crime very seriously, and I believe what these two individuals attempted to do was not only dishonorable but also criminal," Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Michael C. O’Malley said in a statement.

On Sept. 30, Runyan and Cominsky competed at the Lake Erie Walleye Trail tournament, which hosts fishermen from several surrounding states that compete to see which team can catch five of the heaviest walleye fish in Lake Erie, according to authorities. 

Runyan and Cominski would have received $28,760 in prizes for winning the tournament.

However, Lake Erie Walleye Trail tournament director Jason Fischer noticed that Runyan and Cominsky’s walleyes weighed more than they looked and sliced open the fish, authorities said. Ten weights were located inside the walleyes, eight weighing 12 ounces and two weighing 8 ounces, along with several walleye filets. 

Widely-shared video on social media showed a crowd of people at Gordon Park watching Fischer cut the walleye open and announce that there were weights and walleye fillets stuffed inside.


Runyan and Cominsky were immediately disqualified and instructed to leave the tournament. An officer from the Ohio Department of Natural Resources confiscated the fish as evidence.

Officers from ODNR, the Hermitage Police Department, and the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission seized a boat, trailer, and fishing gear belonging to Cominski on Tuesday in Pennsylvania. The anglers had used the boat during last month's tournament, the affidavits said.

One of the affidavits disclosed that Runyan and Cominski were also investigated by Rossford police in northwest Ohio in April after being accused of cheating in a different walleye tournament. According to a Rossford police report, an assistant Wood County prosecutor concluded that although the men may have cheated, there was not enough evidence to charge them.

RELATED: Ohio mayor suggests ice fishing in park could lead to prostitution

This story was reported from Cincinnati. The Associated Press contributed.