Michigan Republican ordered to write essay about bullying after making threatening call to Democrat

Matthew Smith, photo via Facebook page. 

The leader of the Flint-area Republican Party who made a harassing phone call to a Democratic official in the Upper Peninsula was placed on probation Tuesday and ordered to write an essay about the effects of bullying.

Matthew Smith, 24, was accused of calling Jennifer Kelly, the elected clerk in Houghton County, and threatening to poison her dogs during a 1 a.m. phone call in March 2020. A buddy was running against her.

Smith vigorously denied any threats against dogs but pleaded guilty in November to malicious use of a phone.

"I apologize for calling Miss Kelly and making a political phone call late at night," Smith told MLive.com outside court. "You should never make a phone to someone late at night and spook them or startle them."

MORE: Michigan harvester ordered to pay nearly $120K in restitution after stealing timber

Besides leading the Genesee County GOP, Smith is a school board member in Davison. The controversy has led to a recall effort against him.

Smith must perform 240 hours of community service and pay $650. His record eventually will be scrubbed clean if he stays out of trouble.

Judge William Crawford said Smith had "credibility issues" because he initially denied making a call to Smith.

"It’s time to grow up and be a man," the judge said.

MORE: Detroit congressional election races heating up

Kelly, a Democrat, said Smith succeeded in scaring her.

"I have been afraid to go outside. I have avoided functions. I have feared losing my animals," she told the judge via Zoom.